Statistic Reports for American Idol Top 24
Change Pool

Reports: Voting Report     Top 5 Pools     Overall Winner Picks     Season Report    

American Idol elimination predictions American Idol Top 24  
Overall Winner Picks
Rank Name Contestant Total Overall Picks
1 David Archuleta American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
44.7 %
2 Carly Smithson
Eliminated in week 10
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
14.8 %
3 David Cook American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
14.8 %
4 Brooke White
Eliminated in week 11
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
7.3 %
5 Michael Johns
Eliminated in week 8
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
5.9 %


6 Ramiele Malubay
Eliminated in week 7
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
4.0 %
7 Jason Castro
Eliminated in week 12
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
3.8 %
8 Syesha Mercado
Eliminated in week 13
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
1.4 %
9 Kristy Lee Cook
Eliminated in week 9
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.8 %
10 Amanda Overmyer
Eliminated in week 5
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.7 %
11 Chikezei Eze
Eliminated in week 6
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.6 %
12 David Hernandez
Eliminated in week 4
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.4 %
13 Kady Malloy
Eliminated in week 3
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.4 %
14 Asia'h Epperson
Eliminated in week 3
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.3 %
15 Danny Noriega
Eliminated in week 3
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.1 %
16 Alex Lushington
Eliminated in week 2
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.0 %
17 Luke Menard
Eliminated in week 3
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.0 %
18 Jason Yeager
Eliminated in week 2
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.0 %
19 Joanne Borgella
Eliminated in week 1
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.0 %
20 Robbie Carrico
Eliminated in week 2
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner!
0.0 %
21 Colton Berry
Eliminated in week 1
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner! 0.0 %
22 Amy Davis
Eliminated in week 1
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner! 0.0 %
23 Garrett Haley
Eliminated in week 1
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner! 0.0 %
24 Alaina Whitaker
Eliminated in week 2
American Idol Top 24 predicted winner! 0.0 %

This report shows the percentage of time a contestant is selected to be the overall winner.
Only picks made are counted.

Previous Games

  • NFL Pick'em Game
  • NFL Survivor Game
  • NCAA College Football Pick'em Game
  • NCAA College Football Bowl Pick'em Game
  • March Madness Office Pool
  • The Oscars Pick'em Game
  • CBS Survivor Game
  • The Amazing Race Game
  • Dancing with the Stars Game
  • American Idol Game